A Second Opinion is Your First Choice

Do you sign the surgical consent form?

The decision to pursue or decline a recommended medical or surgical procedure is one of the most difficult situations faced by patients impacting their short and long-term health.

I have discussed these decisions with thousands of patients and their families before invasive cardiac procedures like heart catheterizations and stent implants (which I am trained to do) and heart bypass and valve surgery (which my colleagues, heart surgeons, perform). There are over 3 millions of these procedures performed annually in the USA alone, many in outpatients with no or stable symptoms. These procedures have risks of death, heart attack, stroke and other complications that can exceed 5% of those treated.

When powerful new scientific data become available, it is even more pressing to consider all options as practice patterns change very slowly.

In April 2020 The ISCHEMIA Study (costing over $100 million) was published. The study randomized over 5,000 “serious” heart patients with stable angina chest pain and very abnormal stress tests to proceeding directly to heart catheterization, stents or bypass surgery versus NO procedure. The study involved both men and women. The non-surgical group was treated with medications, diet, fitness and abstinence from smoking. Participants were followed for over 3 years. The results were stunning and showed that there were NO differences between the 2 groups for death rates and other end primary endpoints.

What can a heart patient do when faced with a recommendation for an invasive procedure?

The ISCHEMIA study did not include patients in the midst of a heart attack or true medical emergencies. There are patients, particularly those with recurrent and life-threatening symptoms being treated as in-patients in hospitals, who are in an urgent situation requiring an invasive procedure. Fortunately, most heart patients are stable and are outpatients when they are faced with making a decision about a procedure. In my experience, it is very difficult for a patient and their families to challenge a recommendation for a procedure. A list of questions to ask may be of help. Here are some questions worth asking the medical team:

1) Are you familiar with The ISCHEMIA study and can I be treated like the conservative group?

2) Can you refer me to an intensive cardiac rehabilitation (ICR) program like Pritikin ICR and Ornish ICR which my insurance will pay for?

3) Can I have external counterpulsation therapy (ECP) which my insurance will pay for?

4) Can I be referred to a preventive cardiologist to pursue lifestyle changes that go even further than The ISCHEMIA study?

The value of a 2nd opinion from a heart specialist who has no “skin in the game” cannot be overemphasized. For outpatients contemplating invasive procedures, there is usually time to schedule a 2nd opinion. I have performed many of these assessments and, on occasion, have even done this for hospitalized patients.

Advances in cardiac care, including invasive procedures, have improved both the quality and quantity of life for many sick patients. Nonetheless, many heart procedures are performed in patients that could have had the option to safely take medication and change their lifestyle.  Some of these patients suffered tragic complications that could have been avoided.

Whenever possible, a 2nd opinion should be the 1st choice.


P.S. Check out Dr. Kahn's favorite natural product for arterial health here!



Dr. Joel Kahn

You Might Also Enjoy...

A Young Heart Requires Aged Garlic: A Science Superfood

The nutrients derived from whole plant foods repeatedly show health benefits. Some have unique science data and garlic is one of those. Research has shown that the concentrated components of aged garlic, even odorless, are a powerhouse for the heart

Vitamin C and Lipoprotein(a): The Evidence for Benefit

Lipoprotein(a) is an inherited cholesterol particle effected 20-25% of all persons on the planet and it can harm arteries and heart valves throughout life. Standard therapies currently available are not approved for lowering this particle.

The Daniel Fast: 21 Days to Better Metabolic Health

Not everything new is better. An ancient 21 day diet plan from the Bible called the Daniel Fast has been tested at a major university to see if it would improve measures of metabolic health. The results how "there is nothing new under the sun".

Can Infrared Sauna Therapy Heal Your Health?

It may seem a stretch to view a sauna as a path to preserving health or even reversing disease. In reality, there are many impactful research studies showing benefits for heart health, blood pressure, and weight control. Consider sauna as a therapy!